The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe Door that Needs To Stay Shut

I. Am. Prince Caspian. 

The words that first captured my heart and bonded it forever to C. S. Lewis’ Narnia. 

I mean, what could be better than Ben Barnes’ brown eyes looking at you through the screen while he talks to you in a Telmarine accent?

Ok, so I’m a Narnia nerd. And a big Ben Barnes fan. 

I’ve watched all three installments of the original Disney series it feels like at least 47 times each.

Each time I fall in love with them all over again. 

The beauty of the landscape, the fantastic casting, and the lovely truth of Lewis’s allegory get me every time.  It’s like a wardrobe in more ways than one: a door into something extraordinary. 

So understandably, I was beyond ecstatic to hear Greta Gerwig herself, famed director of “Little Women” and “Barbie”, would be adapting “The Magician’s Nephew” for film, set to release Feb. 12, 2027. 

Until I watched that darn trailer! 

The first indication that unfortunately, this would NOT be anywhere close to an Andrew Adamson film was the soundtrack. 

Gerwig chose to use some funky sci-fi, punk rock music? Really?

Now hear me out. I could just be a sci-fi hater. But in my humble opinion, Narnia is solidly in the fantasy realm. To use…whatever punk rock THAT is…is honestly just disrespectful. 

Did you read the book, Greta? Just double checking for the peanut gallery. 

In addition, the colors of the darn thing made me feel like I was on a merry-go-round. Part of the appeal of the original films was the dreamy, ethereal palette, especially the muted greens and foamy blues. 

You feel immersed in calm. 

In contrast, this trailer’s colors scream at you with reds as bright as stop signs. 

Why are you trying to make me dizzy?

Then, to cap it all off…

Why am I hearing Meryl. Streep. As. Aslan?

Goodness gracious. 

Now, hear me out. I’m not disputing Streep’s talent. She has thrived in the industry for decades for a reason. From “Devil Wears Prada” to “Mamma Mia!”, she has consistently shown audiences her adaptability and flexibility as an actress.

But… 

Aslan?

For the uninformed, Aslan is the central character of the series. Lewis crafted him specifically as a lion to be a careful representation of Christ.

A lion, not a lioness. 

Now, before anyone accuses me of theology-bombing, I’m well aware God possesses feminine characteristics. Matthew 23:27 tells us He compared himself to a “hen gathering her chicks.” 

He possesses nurturing instincts like a mother, and holds us and comforts us in our sorrows. But we must remember Jesus Christ entered the world as a male. Just because he possesses qualities traditionally associated with the female sex doesn’t give anyone the right to fiddle with the crucial threads of this allegory. 

He is power contained. He is gentle and tender, but an advocate and defender of those who are His own. 

In my opinion, Liam Neeson embodied all these qualities in a remarkable way. 

So why are we switching it up? 

Why are we so obsessed with changing classic books to fit culture, instead of letting culture be shaped by them instead? What if the beauty of the original films was because Adamson didn’t tamper with the original message? 

Sasha, you’re reading too much into this. 

Maybe. But maybe this isn’t about the film anymore. 

Maybe it’s about a society that tries so hard to be “woke”, “inclusive,” and “tolerant” that we end up pleasing no one. 

Maybe it’s about a director who consistently tramples on Christianity. She says she has respect for it, but then deliberately makes artistic choices she knows will outrage people of faith. 

Now, don’t get me wrong. I like Gerwig. I think her casting and adaptation of “Little Women” was magnificent (although I’ll never forgive her for making Jo write a letter begging Teddy to take her back). 

But I don’t believe she’s doing this for kicks and giggles or to incorporate diversity.

I believe she’s doing it to make a statement about how the world views the Almighty. 

A statement I cannot, and will never get behind:

 God can be to you whatever you want Him (or her??) to be. 

That wardrobe door needs to stay shut. 

About Sasha James 6 Articles
Sasha James is a junior Communication Studies major and serves as Co-Arts & Entertainment Editor for Cardinal & Cream. When she’s not writing or editing stories, she can usually be found drinking coffee, reading a good book, or taking a sunset walk. Above all, she strives to exemplify Christ in everything she does and is always up for a meaningful conversation about Him!

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*